Serbia: Temerin City, Their Animal ‘Shelter’, Death After 3 Days and a (National) Public Attorney Who Says All Is Ok !

In the city of Temerin, which is located near to the city of Novi Sad, a firm named ‘JKP Temerin’ operates as the garbage collection company.  In Temerin is a ‘dog and cat shelter’, given a permit for use by the Direcctor of Veterinary department of Serbia, Mr Micovic.

UPDATE 06/05/10 – New photographs of the Temerin ‘shelter’ can be seen on our other post at:

https://serbiananimalsvoice.wordpress.com/2010/05/06/serbia-exclusive-pictures-of-jkp-termerin-temerin-city-dog-and-cat-shelter/ 

 

Some very Important points to be considered: 

After three days at the ‘shelter’, dogs are taken to Novi Sad city where they are killed by ‘euthanasia’, using Pravilnik 29/94 legislation.

Prior to the new Serbian Veterinary Law of 02/10/2005, there was an old law dating from 1991 for the health protection of animals. In agreement with the old law of 1991, the authorities produced their own other ‘underlaw’ (extra law) regulationnamed ‘Pravilnik 29/94’, which was intorduced to allow the killing of animals after they were held in pounds for 3 to 7 days.

** From 02/10/2005, the new Veterinary Law Article 168 effectively destroyed everything that was written in Pravilnik 29/94, ** because the 2005 law demanded the care of animals.

Pravilnik 29/94 was overwritten by Article 168, the result being that all killing of animals was forbidden apart only from cases for Rabies infected areas, which were covered by application of Articles 64 and 65 of the Veterinary Law.

By continuing to undertake the killing of animals after 3 to 7 days in accordance with regulation Pravilnik 29/94, the authorities were then in a situation where they were working in opposition to the actual existing law

But it is very much the case, even up to the present day, where authorities are still using Pravilnik 29/94 as a reason for the killing of animals.  But in reality, Pravilnik 29/94 became nonexistent on 02/10/2005 with the introduction of the new Veterinary Law (Article 168)

Hence there should be no killing, but animal care instead.

Pravilnik 29/94 is only an ‘underlaw’ (extra law) regulation, has very less power than the actual law, and most importantly, must be in agreement with the existing lawPravilnik 29/94 was valid originally (1991 on) to protect animal health but is now in opposition to the new and current animal law – the new Veterinary Law Article 168 of 02/10/2005.

Serbian campaigners have written to the Constitutional Court saying that it is unlawful for Shinters (Dogcatchers) and also veterinarians to kill stray dogs and cats only after they have been held for three (3) days, as this is now old and outdated legislation.  Killing is forbidden under the new Veterinary law.

Campaigners have now heard from the court in writing, and they say that no analysis of the case is necessary for Pravilnik 29/94 as it has been replaced by the new Veterinary Law Article 168 (02/10/2005). 

This is exactly what the campaigners had said, ie. that the old ‘underlaw’ (extra law) of Pravilnik 29/94 was still being used when it fact it has been overwritten by the new Veterinary Law Article 168 of 02/10/2005.

In addition, Article 46 of the new Veterinary Law (02/10/2005) states that the killing of stray cats and dogs is forbidden and that instead they should be provided with care.

The word from the Serbian Constitutional (law) Court is that from 2005, animals should be provided with care and not be killed.

It would appear that all of the public firms responsible for garbage collection in Serbian cities are still working to, and effectively using Pravilnik 29/94 rather than Article 46 (168) of the new Veterinary Law

In effect, by still working to this now non existent law, these public firms who collect and kill strays are UNDERTAKING ILLEGAL WORK– they should be working in accordace with the new Veterinary Law Article 46 (168) of 02/10/2005 which demands care for the animals.

Unlike the Temerin ‘shelter’ dogs which are illegally killed after only 3 days, Cats which are taken to the ‘shelter’ do not even live three days – they are killed immediately.

A detailed explanation of the legislation is given in our past SAV Link:

https://serbiananimalsvoice.wordpress.com/2010/01/25/serbia-constitutional-court-of-serbia-says-that-the-killing-of-stray-dogs-and-cats-in-serbia-is-forbidden-from-02102005/ 

Serbian campaigners have now taken this case to the court of human rights in Strasbourg – an EU court.  The caseGarbage collectors in Serbian cities are still working using the (now) non existent Pravilnik 29/94 rather than Article 46 (168) of the new and current Veterinary Law of 02/10/2005 which demands care.  In addition, campaigners have requested justification be presented for all the animal killings by the authorities from 02/10/2005 right up to the present day.

Serbian authorities  and officials are responsible for ensuring the correct laws are implemented are:

  • Mrs. Sanja Čelebićanin  -Chief of  Veterinary Inspection
  • Mr. Zoran Mićović – Director of Veterinary Department
  • Mr. Radivoje Kaurin – Chief of  Hunting – Forests Inspection.

So the situation is that many Serbian authorities are not implementing the most recent and current legislation which would give protection to animals in shelters, but are instead using old and outdated, non existing legislation (Pravilnik 29/94) as justification for the continued killing of animals held in shelters.

Another very important factor here is that what has been happening since 02/10/2005 is that existing Serbian law (legislation) has not been implemented throughout the country in relation to animal welfare.

Probably the most important point:

And the proof of the implementation of the ‘Rule of Law’ is a paramount requirement for any nation wishing to become a future member of the EU !

And so what about the ‘Shelter’ for animals at Temerin ?

We declare that the alleged ‘shelter’ at Temerin is NOT shelter but a terrible, unlawful place being funded by Serbian taxpayers to the tune of many millions of Dinars.

Is this facility simply a place that takes in public money allegedly caring for animals, whilst at the same time killing them immediately (cats) or after just three days (dogs) using outdated legislation which was replaced in 2005 ? – we think so.

Animals such as these dogs and cats which are taken from the streets by shinter teams, are not marked or identified in any way.  There is no way that the authorities can provide details of the animals taken by the shinters, be it 10 dogs or 100 dogs captured.  In effect, with no accountability of their work, these public firms can ask for as much public money as they wish – and very often / always they are provided with it !!

Can this be called ‘organised crime’ ?

If a full sterilisation, vaccination, identification and care system was established for all stray animals taken by the shinters, then the facilities such as the Temerin ‘shelter’ would be very much more accountable (ie. Record keeping) of all animals which enter the facility.

As it is, by using old, outdated, self created (mass killing) legislation such as Pravilnik 29/94 rather than working to what should be current animal protection legislation, (ie. Article 46 (168) of the new and current Veterinary Law of 02/10/2005), the authorities and those involved with it appear to in a situation where they can request, and are provided with an endless supply of public money – public money for killing animalsWHICH IS ILLEGAL (since 2005).

—————————————————————————

In addition:

The man wearing the black hat in the picture below is Tamas Paska.

Serbian animal campaigners have made several criminal charges against him in the past.

By chance, Paska also lives in Temerin City (detailed above).

The photographs which you can see (above and below) in this post have been presented by Serbian campaigners to both the police and to the Public Attorney of Novi Sad, the city  near to Paska’s city of Temerin.

We have been provided with names of persons engaged in similar organised animal fights on the city of Subotica.  Animal fights which are undertaken at individuals homes.

Photographs :  Legal ? – ‘Yes’, it would appear, according to the Serbian Public Attorney

In response to the evidence, some of which is shown here, as well as names of individuals involved and the cities in which these crimes are undertaken, the Serbian public Attorney has written to welfare activists and stated that ‘there are no elements of any crime or any criminal act’.

Because of this, and the fact that they know they are safe under the statements issued by the Serbian Public Attorney, Paska and the others continue to undertake their ‘non criminal’ acts, as you can see in the photographs.

With Public Attorney officials and police such as this, one has to ask who actually controls and heads all of this animal fighting crime ? – but then it is not a crime; campaigners presenting the evidence have been told all of this !

Implementation of the ‘Rule of Law’ is a paramount requirement for any nation wishing to become a future member of the EU !

…. And that should include Serbia; but does it ?

–          a point that we would argue given this evidence and the declarations made by the Serbian ‘legislators’ – the Public Attorney.

This data , including photographs, information and the responses of the Serbian Public Attorney, as well as the information relating to the situation at the Temerin City ‘shelter’ will now be presented to the officials of the EU.

Lets hope and trust that they take more action to fight crime than the Serbian officials and police!

26 Responses

  1. Temerin City Serbia you should be ashamed of yourselves taking money under false pretence to look after animals and you don’t look after them you KILL them shame on you. Also as the pictures have shown dog fighting this is also disgusting and must stop these people who do these awfull acts of cruelty should be publicly flogged they are a disgrace. Serbia must get itsself sorted out and have good laws protetecting unwanted animals and also make sure poeple stick to the law or jail them. What happends in Serbia to animals is shocking and I am disgusted with what I have heard and seen so get it sorted.

  2. I can’t look at those phots it makes me cry, why are some people so heartless and cruel and abusive to our best friends I will never understand those humans and I don’t want to THEY ARE MONSTERS. I think someone needs to help those poor dogs in cages they can hardly move. JUST AWFUL, who ever is close by please help them.

  3. What we need are addresses, phone numbers, emails where we can voice our anger and disgust.

  4. I am so sad for these poor dogs. They never asked for this kind of treatment. Criminal, barbaric, cruel, inhuman, are just some of the adjectives that come to mind. I am ashamed to be associated, as a human being, with these people!

  5. To scream “SHAME ON YOU” wouldn’t help, the response of these sadists would be laughter and satisfaction….we need ways to fight them, and to prevent other atrocities….PETITIONS, EMAILS …..

  6. no words can help these poor poor animals,i feel nothing but hatred and a great desire to kill these vile people

  7. this is disgusting these people need to be punished this sickens me i hope they get what they deserve

  8. YOU PEOPLE THAT DO THIS TO ANIMALS ARE SICK I HOPE GOD SHOWS YOU THE SAME TREATMENT AND WORSE
    THIS SHOULD BE STOPED ………………………………….

  9. THE PEOPLE WHO LET THIS HAPPEN SHOULD BE DEAD OR HAD NEVER BEEN BORN.

  10. за убийства невинных животных, эти нелюди должны отвечать по закону,берёте деньги за животных на благие дела для ухода, а сами убиваете, убийцы животных должны нести наказание, сидеть в тюрьме.

  11. These people are cowards. The animals have more courage then these slime-buckets. Put them in a small cage and watch them shrivel up to nothing.

  12. STOP THAT CRUELTY!!!!!!!!!!!

  13. it’s a shame !! I knew there were cruel men, but I see that also women are sick in their head. They should be punished and tortured as well. So they can feel what they are doing to this beautiful loyal creatures !!

  14. These people are vile and disgusting and should be severed from any population.

  15. This is totally cruel and wrong. We need to treat those animals as living creatures and help them not abuse and kill them. Please help stop these cruel actions. 6/12/2013

  16. it is monstrous, it’s revolting, it makes me nauseous, stop these filthy and bestial cruelty. You are monsters and barbarians

  17. Non à l’adhésion de la Serbie à l’Union Européenne, tant qu’il n’y aura pas de loi contre ces atrocités! C’est une honte!

  18. People are so cruel!! I just cant imagine how they could look at these poor dogs, and treat in such a inhuman manner. In my opinion they should be all gathered up and boiled alive..

  19. They should suffer a long painful death, disgusting sods.

  20. This reflects such a low level of awareness that it is almost impossible to fatham how it is possible. What do you want us to do to take action? There is a growing voice around the world that will join you – thank you for your long dossier and please begin an easy action that people can sign, share, twitter and the voice will get louder. Thank you for leading the way – well done!

  21. […] 2010, na mesma altura em que o vídeo foi feito, já tinha havido a denúncia da Servial Animals Voice das condições humilhantes em que os cães tinham más condições mesmo com a criação de uma […]

  22. you animal cruelty people scum should all be taken to justice in a diffrent state, and deported to a island for the rest of you misreable live, with none chance for coming back, and that includes the authority who also support animal cruelty.

  23. Write more, thats all I have to say.Literally, itt seems as though you relied oon the video to make your point.
    You definittely know what youre talking about, why throw away yoour intelligenhce on just postging videos to your blog when yoou could be giving
    us something informative to read?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: